Jump to content

Welcome to Dual Universe
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. This message will be removed once you have signed in.
Login to Account Create an Account
Photo

Debate 9: Tech Tree Thoughts

Debate Debate 9 Tech Tree Thoughts Concepts Concept

  • Please log in to reply
44 replies to this topic

#1
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

Debate 9: Tech Tree Thoughts

 

The long awaited return of the old debate topics is upon us, after a long hiatus of working on my doctorate I have decided to return to them as we traverse this wonderful road to alpha.

 

     Today I awoke with a simple thought, "How are the developers of Dual Universe ie Novaquark planning on structuring their tech tree system?" As far as I see it there are several ways that it can be approached, however, to keep things simple I will limit it just two ideas on the subject. Feel free to read through it, take to heart my opinions, or feel free to formulate your own or expand on pre existing ones, all feedback is welcome.
 

 

Linear Tree: ‚ÄčThis is the classic form of tech tree you see standardized in most games, it starts with usually a single item / tech then spreads along in a sub linear fashion, one tech leading to others along a fixed path. To me this is usually generalized and can end up fairly repetitive.

 

Circular / Adaptive Tree: ‚ÄčThis form of tech tree is generally more complicated but it allows for greater diversification. It allows you to have specific areas of science/technology researched - that lead to other sections of the circle that unlock as you go along. In my opinion this allows technology to be approached in a non linear fashion that is never dull, instead allowing asymmetric progression through the system - focusing in one area one day - in another the next.

 

Of course all of this is nothing but hypothetical, so feel free to do your own research on the concepts, post your thoughts, feelings, ideas below; and remember - just have fun!

 

We will be there before you know it.


  • Aetherios likes this

---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#2
Lynkx

Lynkx

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 110 posts
  • LocationSome where between worlds !
  • Silver Founder

when you say "tech tree" you mean the player skills ? The craftable items ? or everything ?


ixiNee5.jpg


#3
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

when you say "tech tree" you mean the player skills ? The craftable items ? or everything ?

Researchable technologies in general.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#4
Lethys

Lethys

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1222 posts
  • LocationAustria
  • Ruby Founder
I'd like to see a mix between Civilization (many low level techs/skills needed for higher ones) and master if Orion (whole branches can be researched without the need if other branches).

I don't quite get what you mean by that circular tree though

#5
Pang_Dread

Pang_Dread

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 161 posts
  • Gold Founder

I think the linear branching tree design is probably the simpler thus cheaper way to go. It works so why try to reinvent the wheel. You have categories for each different aspect, weapons, combat, armor, prospecting/scanning, economy etc. Then as they get used you get skill points or such to further in the tree. Simple.


As I take my first steps outside the Ark Ship I look up to the night sky and say to myself... "Can't take the sky from me."


#6
Haunty

Haunty

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 131 posts
  • LocationMN, United States
  • Sapphire Founder

Would like to see a visual example of what a circular tree looks like


duaalogo.png


#7
Falstaf

Falstaf

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 911 posts
  • Gold Founder
I always enjoyed the way Civ did it.
But I dont think that translates well for a game like DU.

I want to be a miner so I shouldnt be diverted to researching trading skills. Its not a great example but thats how Civ would work.

For Civ it makes sense because you need everything, I'm not sure the same holds true for a game like DU.

Just some thoughts on the subject, I'm interested to read other people's ideas.

9oTTEuQ.jpg


#8
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

Samples were requested - 

 

Linear sample -GCICziidC.jpg

 

 

 

Circular/Web sample -

 

4gh0Y4wfA.jpg


---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#9
Lethys

Lethys

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1222 posts
  • LocationAustria
  • Ruby Founder

I always enjoyed the way Civ did it.
But I dont think that translates well for a game like DU.

I want to be a miner so I shouldnt be diverted to researching trading skills. Its not a great example but thats how Civ would work.

For Civ it makes sense because you need everything, I'm not sure the same holds true for a game like DU.

Just some thoughts on the subject, I'm interested to read other people's ideas.


As I said: combine it with master of orion. You can research all skills as miner without the need for skilling pvp or trade

#10
mrjacobean

mrjacobean

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 286 posts
  • LocationAboard the Black Codex
  • Gold Founder

You could also add something similar to diablo 2, where having some skills/techs improves others. For example, having skills in using mining lasers helps with using combat lasers.



#11
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

I was also thinking about main techs - and under each main tech has various sub techs. . . and from those sub techs can potentially lead to secondary techs or other main techs which branch off. 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#12
Falstaf

Falstaf

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 911 posts
  • Gold Founder

As I said: combine it with master of orion. You can research all skills as miner without the need for skilling pvp or trade


I'll google that game.;)
I dont think I've played it.

9oTTEuQ.jpg


#13
wizardoftrash

wizardoftrash

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 443 posts
  • LocationStuck in the Arkship still
  • Gold Founder

Since the devs have mentioned often the need and incentive for players to be specialists, we will likely see a highly segregated linear skill system. From what the devs have already mentioned, a player would be able to pick up basic skills in each category very quickly, but will take much longer to acquire an advanced skill form one category. They also mentioned in the discussion of Alloys that the advanced skills in each category will depend on other skills in that same category, this reinforces that their vision is of a linear tree.

 

We are unlikely to see situations where for example being able to manufacture an advanced Armor alloy will give you access to an advanced Hull Repair skill, as manufacturing/refining will be a different specialization from Logistics/repairs. This will probably be the case at launch, but who knows where they will go from there. Alpha might not include much in the way of character progression, so we likely won't have a firm grasp of this until beta much later.


tumblr_oozd3gLt491uqxh5so1_540.png

Join the Free Lancers , the Squires, the Wayward, or the Alchemists today!

Get a free Greetz Puppy in-game Cosmetic Sticker!

(My gaming blog) http://wizardoftrash.tumblr.com/


#14
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

You could also add something similar to diablo 2, where having some skills/techs improves others. For example, having skills in using mining lasers helps with using combat lasers.

Have any examples for comparison - to add to the list? For purely visual reference. . .


---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#15
WilksCheckov

WilksCheckov

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 316 posts
  • LocationDeveloping political entities!

As I said: combine it with master of orion. You can research all skills as miner without the need for skilling pvp or trade

 

You could also add something similar to diablo 2, where having some skills/techs improves others. For example, having skills in using mining lasers helps with using combat lasers.

 

Could you provide some visual reference as to how the systems are organized - It would go a long ways as to helping conceptualize the idea. 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -

signature_B51_KVKFJ.png

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- -- -


#16
mrjacobean

mrjacobean

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 286 posts
  • LocationAboard the Black Codex
  • Gold Founder

Have any examples for comparison - to add to the list? For purely visual reference. . .

Hmm, its been a while... I know that in diablo 2, whilst playing a necromancer, upping any summon skeleton spells (warrior, mage and mimic) will improve the others (i.e. their stats increased the more skill points you put into it), but less so than putting points into the others directly.

 

Getting examples in DU is hard, since I have no clue what the skill tree would be like. I guess improving your vehicle construction skill (maybe used in fabricators) would reduce the decay rate or improve the repair rate of any vehicle you are a crew member of (due to more knowledge of maintaining machines coming from building them).

 

EDIT: To quote from the diablo 2 wiki:

 

 

Skill Synergy Bonuses
Synergy bonuses will boost the effectiveness of the higher-level skills based upon the number of points you place in lower-level skills. This gives players an incentive to use their skill points earlier in the game, rather than keeping them, and using them only for high-level skills. If a skill has a Synergy, the other skills that will help improve the skill will be listed. Items that give bonuses to skills and skill levels do not add to Synergy bonuses. 


#17
Begogian

Begogian

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 175 posts
  • LocationWouldn't You Like To Know
  • Silver Founder

I think the Circular Tech Tree would make the most sense because that means each character can be unique based on their knowledge along with the ability to chose specific topics to focus on learning. It could allow for diversity and would also lead to more detail professions


Evil Inc. is recruiting!    Efficient.    Effective.    Evil is as Evil Does!


#18
Lethys

Lethys

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1222 posts
  • LocationAustria
  • Ruby Founder

I think the Circular Tech Tree would make the most sense because that means each character can be unique based on their knowledge along with the ability to chose specific topics to focus on learning. It could allow for diversity and would also lead to more detail professions

 

That's true but to me it doesn't make any sense to skill Trade and then somehow get to heavy firearms...

 

A straight forward techtree like EVE, Master of orion, Civ,... makes much more sense. You can skill one field of expertise while needing only those basic skills in that branch.

Synergy bonuses are a must in a game like DU imho, so you can maximize your abilities in some branch



#19
Begogian

Begogian

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 175 posts
  • LocationWouldn't You Like To Know
  • Silver Founder

That's true but to me it doesn't make any sense to skill Trade and then somehow get to heavy firearms...

 

A straight forward techtree like EVE, Master of orion, Civ,... makes much more sense. You can skill one field of expertise while needing only those basic skills in that branch.

Synergy bonuses are a must in a game like DU imho, so you can maximize your abilities in some branch

 

What if it was structured like the Ideology Tree in Civ 5 but opposite? You start with 2 slots and can choose from 10 different Tier 1 skills. After unlocking enough you can then move to Tier 2 which gives you more skills and has 5 slots, so on and so forth..... Looks like this:

 

http://vignette1.wik...=20141228172533


Evil Inc. is recruiting!    Efficient.    Effective.    Evil is as Evil Does!


#20
Lethys

Lethys

    Advanced Member

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1222 posts
  • LocationAustria
  • Ruby Founder

yeah that makes sense.

 

To me all such trees are very similar, they may vary in size and prerequisitions but in fact, EVE onlines skill tree is no different from Civilization - whatever they choose, it should take time to specialize and it should allow players to do so.

Because only then newbros will be allowed to take part in fights or industry, because they can participate, even if they have low skills.







Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Debate, Debate 9, Tech Tree, Thoughts, Concepts, Concept

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users